MADE IN THE USA
SemiHandMade, Nieu, and CabinetNow: Price and Finish Comparison for IKEA Replacement Cabinet Doors
Upgrading your kitchen with IKEA replacement cabinet doors is a smart way to give your space a fresh look without the cost of a full remodel. But how do you choose the right replacement cabinet doors with so many options on the market? In this article, we'll compare the price and finishes of popular IKEA replacement cabinet doors from three leading brands: SemiHandMade, Nieu, and CabinetNow.
At CabinetNow, we pride ourselves on offering high-quality, affordable finishes that meet or exceed the quality of competitors. Let’s dive into the finishes and pricing to help you make the best choice for your kitchen upgrade.
Why Finishes Matter for IKEA Replacement Cabinet Doors
When choosing IKEA replacement cabinet doors, the finish plays a crucial role in both the visual appeal and durability of your kitchen. The finish you choose can change the overall ambiance, texture, and color depth of the room, so it’s important to consider your style preferences and practical needs.
Thermofoil Finishes
Thermofoil finishes for IKEA cabinet doors are perfect for a modern, minimalist aesthetic. Their smooth, non-reflective surfaces offer a subtle and high-end look, often favored in contemporary kitchens. Supermatte finishes take it a step further by offering a velvety texture that minimizes fingerprints and smudges—ideal for high-traffic areas. Thermfoil cabinet doors which are MDF doors at the core with a vinyl laminate heated and pressurized perfect for a high quality and lasting finish that is ready to install upon arrival.
Wood Grain Thermofoil Finishes
If you prefer a more rustic, natural look, wood grain finishes bring warmth and texture to your kitchen. The natural patterns of wood grain offer an authentic, crafted feel, seamlessly blending with both traditional and transitional design elements. Wood grain finishes also offer a timeless look that can elevate any kitchen.
Solid Wood, MDF, and Veneer
In addition to finishes, the material of the cabinet door is just as important. Whether you’re opting for solid wood, MDF, or veneer, the material influences the durability, appearance, and cost of your IKEA replacement cabinet doors.
- Solid Wood (Hardwood): The premium choice, providing natural grain patterns and a rich, durable aesthetic.
- MDF (Medium-Density Fiberboard): Engineered for durability and often used for matte and gloss finishes due to its smooth, even surface.
- Veneer: Combines the beauty of wood with a cost-effective engineered material, allowing for high-end finishes at a lower price.
Comparing Custom IKEA Replacement Cabinet Door Prices and Finishes
Let’s take a look at how CabinetNow compares with other popular brands, focusing on price and finish options for 12x30 replacement IKEA cabinet doors. For this comparison, we’re focusing on three key brands: SemiHandMade, Nieu, and CabinetNow, reviewing their prices for popular styles and matching finishes.
|
Product Name
SemiHandMade
|
Price
SemiHandMade
|
Lead Times
SemiHandMade
|
Product Name
Nieu
|
Price
Nieu
|
Lead Times
Nieu
|
Product Name
CabinetNow
|
Price
CabinetNow
|
Lead Times
CabinetNow
| CabinetNow Product Link | CabinetNow Product Image |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|
SemiHandmade
DIY Shaker Door (MDF Panel / Maple Frame)
| $95.00 | 5-6 Weeks |
Nieu
Raw Shaker (MDF)
| $65.77 | 3-4 Weeks |
CabinetNow
Unfinished Shaker Cabinet Door ¾” (Maple panel / paintable hardwood frame)
| $65.05 | 5-7 Business Days | Unfinished Shaker Door |
|
|
SemiHandmade
DIY Quartline Door (MDF Panel / Maple Frame)
| $104.00 |
5-6 Weeks
|
Nieu
Raw Skinny Shaker (MDF)
| $98.32 | 3-4 Weeks |
CabinetNow
Unfinished Nashville Door (mdf)
| $85.84 | 5-7 Business Days | Nashville Door |
|
|
SemiHandmade
DIY Slab Door (MDF Panel / Maple Frame)
| $86.00 | 5-6 Weeks |
Nieu
Raw Scandia (MDF)
| $33.18 | 3-4 Weeks |
CabinetNow
Unfinished Arlington (mdf)
| $49.35 | 5-7 Business Days | Arlington Door |
|
|
SemiHandmade
White Quarterline Door (thermofoil)
| $178.00 | 6-7 Weeks |
Nieu
Winter White Skinny Shaker (Painted MDF)
| $173.13 | 5-6 Weeks |
CabinetNow
Ontario White Modern Shaker Slim (thermofoil)
| $108.90 | 10-12 Business Days | Modern Shaker Slim Door |
|
|
SemiHandmade
White Supermatte Slab Door (thermofoil)
| $156.00 | 6-7 Weeks |
Nieu
Winter White Scandia (Painted MDF)
| $92.75 | 5-6 Weeks |
CabinetNow
Ontario White Modern Turino (thermofoil)
| $84.00 | 10-12 Business Days | Modern Turino Door |
|
|
SemiHandmade
White Supermatte Shaker Door (thermofoil)
| $171.00 | 6-7 Weeks |
Nieu
Winter White Shaker (Painted MDF)
| $140.58 | 5-6 Weeks |
CabinetNow
Ontario White Modern Shaker (Thermofoil)
| $108.90 | 10-12 Business Days | Modern Shaker Door |
|
|
SemiHandmade
White SSS Beaded Door (thermofoil)
| $178.00 | 6-7 Weeks |
Nieu
Winter White Cottage Shaker (painted mdf)
| $204.98 | 5-6 Weeks |
CabinetNow
Ontario White Modern Bradford (thermofoil)
| $123.00 | 10-12 Business Days | Modern Bradford Door |
|
|
SemiHandmade
White Supermatte Glass Ready Shaker Door (thermofoil)
| $171.00 | 6-7 Weeks |
Nieu
Winter White Shaker (painted mdf)
| $140.58 | 5-6 Weeks |
CabinetNow
Shaker Open for Glass (hardwood)
| $65.05 |
5-7
Business Days | Shaker Open for Glass |
|
|
SemiHandmade
Stone Quarterline Door (thermofoil)
| $178.00 | 6-7 Weeks |
Nieu
Totally Taupe Skinny Shaker (painted mdf)
| $173.13 | 5-6 Weeks |
CabinetNow
Sahara SuperMatte Modern Shaker Slim (thermofoil)
| $123.00 | 10-12 Business Days | Modern Shaker Slim Door |
|
|
SemiHandmade
Stone Supermatte Shaker Door (thermofoil)
| $171.00 | 6-7 Weeks |
Nieu
Totally Taupe Shaker (painted mdf)
| $140.58 | 5-6 Weeks |
CabinetNow
Sahara SuperMatte Modern Shaker (thermofoil)
| $123.00 | 10-12 Business Days | Modern Shaker Door |
|
|
SemiHandmade
Stone Supermatte Slab Door (thermofoil)
| $156.00 | 6-7 Weeks |
Nieu
Totally Taupe Scandia (painted mdf)
| $92.75 | 5-6 Weeks |
CabinetNow
Sahara SuperMatte Modern Turino (thermofoil)
| $99.60 | 10-12 Business Days | Modern Turino Door |
|
|
SemiHandmade
Stone SSS Beaded Door (thermofoil)
| $178.00 | 6-7 Weeks |
Nieu
Totally Taupe Cottage Shaker (painted mdf)
| $204.98 | 5-6 Weeks |
CabinetNow
Sahara SuperMatte Modern Bradford (thermofoil)
| $138.90 | 10-12 Business Days | Modern Bradford Door |
|
|
SemiHandmade
Night Sky Supermatte Shaker Door (thermofoil)
| $178.00 | 6-7 Weeks |
Nieu
Dream Dusk Shaker (painted mdf)
| $146.88 | 5-6 Weeks |
CabinetNow
Midnight SuperMatte Modern Shaker (thermofoil)
| $123.00 | 10-12 Business Days | Modern Shaker Door |
|
|
SemiHandmade
Night Sky Supermatte Glass Ready Shaker Door (thermofoil)
| $178.00 | 6-7 Weeks |
Nieu
Dream Dusk Shaker (painted mdf)
| $146.88 | 5-6 Weeks |
CabinetNow
Shaker Open for Glass (hardwood)
| $65.05 | 5-7 Business Days | Shaker Open for Glass |
|
|
SemiHandmade
Night Sky Quarterline Door (thermofoil)
| $178.00 | 6-7 Weeks |
Nieu
Dream Dusk Skinny Shaker (painted mdf)
| $179.42 | 5-6 Weeks |
CabinetNow
Midnight SuperMatte Modern Shaker Slim (thermofoil)
| $123.00 | 10-12 Business Days | Modern Shaker Slim Door |
|
|
SemiHandmade
Night Sky Supermatte Slab Door (thermofoil)
| $163.00 | 6-7 Weeks |
Nieu
Dream Dusk Scandia (painted mdf)
| $99.05 | 5-6 Weeks |
CabinetNow
Midnight SuperMatte Modern Turino (thermofoil)
| $99.60 | 10-12 Business Days | Modern Turino Door |
|
|
SemiHandmade
Night Sky SSS Beaded Door (thermofoil)
| $178.00 | 6-7 Weeks |
Nieu
Dream Dusk Cottage Shaker (painted mdf)
| $204.98 | 5-6 Weeks |
CabinetNow
Midnight SuperMatte Modern Bradford (thermofoil)
| $138.90 | 10-12 Business Days | Modern Bradford Door |
|
|
SemiHandmade
Black Quarterline Door (thermofoil)
| $178.00 | 6-7 Weeks |
Nieu
Bonny Black Skinny Shaker (painted mdf)
| $179.42 | 5-6 Weeks |
CabinetNow
Black SmartMatte Modern Shaker Slim (thermofoil)
| $145.20 | 10-12 Business Days | Modern Shaker Slim Door |
|
|
SemiHandmade
Black Supermatte Shaker Door (thermofoil)
| $171.00 | 6-7 Weeks |
Nieu
Bonny Black Shaker (painted mdf)
| $146.88 | 5-6 Weeks |
CabinetNow
Black SmartMatte Modern Shaker (thermofoil)
| $145.00 | 10-12 Business Days | Modern Shaker Door |
|
|
SemiHandmade
Black Supermatte Slab Door (thermofoil)
| $156.00 | 6-7 Weeks |
Nieu
Bonny Black Scandia (painted mdf)
| $99.05 | 5-6 Weeks |
CabinetNow
Black SmartMatte Modern Turino (thermofoil)
| $141.00 | 10-12 Business Days | Modern Turino Door |
|
|
SemiHandmade
Black SSS Beaded Door (thermofoil)
| $178.00 | 6-7 Weeks |
Nieu
Bonny Black Cottage Shaker (painted mdf)
| $211.28 | 5-6 Weeks |
CabinetNow
Black SmartMatte Modern Bradford (thermofoil)
| $158.10 | 10-12 Business Days | Modern Bradford Door |
|
|
SemiHandmade
Black Supermatte Glass Ready Door (thermofoil)
| $170.00 | 6-7 Weeks |
Nieu
Bonny Black Shaker (painted mdf)
| $146.88 | 5-6 Weeks |
CabinetNow
Shaker Open for Glass (hardwood)
| $65.05 | 5-7 Business Days | Shaker Open for Glass |
|
|
SemiHandmade
Desert Grey Quarterline Door (thermofoil)
| $178.00 | 6-7 Weeks |
Nieu
Brightly Beige Skinny Shaker (painted mdf)
| $173.13 |
5-6 Weeks
|
CabinetNow
Haze SuperMatte Modern Shaker Slim (thermofoil)
| $123.00 | 10-12 Business Days | Modern Shaker Slim Door |
|
|
SemiHandmade
Desert Grey Supermatte Shaker Door (thermofoil)
| $178.00 | 6-7 Weeks |
Nieu
Brightly Beige Shaker (painted mdf)
| $140.58 | 5-6 Weeks |
CabinetNow
Haze SuperMatte Modern Shaker (thermofoil)
| $123.00 | 10-12 Business Days | Modern Shaker Door |
|
|
SemiHandmade
Desert Grey Supermatte Slab Door (thermofoil)
| $163.00 | 6-7 Weeks |
Nieu
Brightly Beige Scandia (painted mdf)
| $92.75 | 5-6 Weeks |
CabinetNow
Haze SuperMatte Modern Turino (thermofoil)
| $99.60 | 10-12 Business Days | Modern Turino Door |
|
|
SemiHandmade
Desert Grey SSS Beaded Door (thermofoil)
| $178.00 | 6-7 Weeks |
Nieu
Brightly Beige Cottage Shaker (painted mdf)
| $204.98 | 5-6 Weeks |
CabinetNow
Haze SuperMatte Modern Shaker (thermofoil)
| $138.90 | 10-12 Business Days | Modern Bradford Door |
|
|
SemiHandmade
Moss Supermatte Shaker Door (thermofoil)
| $171.00 | 6-7 Weeks |
Nieu
Sweetly Sage Shaker (painted mdf)
| $146.88 | 5-6 Weeks |
CabinetNow
Sage SuperMatte Modern Shaker (thermofoil)
| $123.00 | 10-12 Business Days | Modern Shaker Door |
|
|
SemiHandmade
Moss Supermatte Glass Ready Shaker Door (thermofoil)
| $170.00 | 6-7 Weeks |
Nieu
Sweetly Sage Shaker (painted mdf)
| $146.88 | 5-6 Weeks |
CabinetNow
Shaker Open for Glass (hardwood)
| $65.05 | 5-7 Business Days | Shaker Open for Glass |
|
|
SemiHandmade
Moss Supermatte Slab Door (thermofoil)
| $156.00 | 6-7 Weeks |
Nieu
Sweetly Sage Scandia (painted mdf)
| $99.05 | 5-6 Weeks |
CabinetNow
Sage SuperMatte Modern Turino (thermofoil)
| $99.60 | 10-12 Business Days | Modern Turino Door |
|
|
SemiHandmade
Moss SSS Beaded Door (thermofoil)
| $178.00 | 6-7 Weeks |
Nieu
Sweetly Sage Cottage Shaker (painted mdf)
| $211.28 | 5-6 Weeks |
CabinetNow
Sage SuperMatte Modern Bradford (thermofoil)
| $138.90 | 10-12 Business Days | Modern Bradford Door |
|
|
SemiHandmade
Moss Quarterline Door (thermofoil)
| $178.00 | 6-7 Weeks |
Nieu
Sweetly Sage Skinny Shaker (painted mdf)
| $179.42 | 5-6 Weeks |
CabinetNow
Sage SuperMatte Modern Shaker Slim (thermofoil)
| $123.00 | 10-12 Business Days | Modern Shaker Slim Door |
|
|
SemiHandmade
Agave Quarterline Door (thermofoil)
| $178.00 | 6-7 Weeks |
Nieu
Trendy Teal Skinny Shaker (painted mdf)
| $179.42 | 5-6 Weeks |
CabinetNow
Denim SuperMatte Modern Shaker Slim (thermofoil)
| $123.00 | 10-12 Business Days | Modern Shaker Slim Door |
|
|
SemiHandmade
Agave Supermatte Shaker Door (thermofoil)
| $178.00 | 6-7 Weeks |
Nieu
Trendy Teal Shaker (painted mdf)
| $140.58 | 5-6 Weeks |
CabinetNow
Denim SuperMatte Modern Shaker (thermofoil)
| $123.00 | 10-12 Business Days | Modern Shaker Door |
|
|
SemiHandmade
Agave Supermatte Slab Door (thermofoil)
| $163.00 | 6-7 Weeks |
Nieu
Trendy Teal Scandia (painted mdf)
| $99.05 | 5-6 Weeks |
CabinetNow
Denim SuperMatte Modern Turino (thermofoil)
| $99.60 | 10-12 Business Days | Modern Turino Door |
|
|
SemiHandmade
Agave SSS Beaded Door (thermofoil)
| $178.00 | 6-7 Weeks |
Nieu
Trendy Teal Cottage Shaker (painted mdf)
| $211.28 | 5-6 Weeks |
CabinetNow
Denim SuperMatte Modern Bradford (thermofoil)
| $138.90 | 10-12 Business Days | Modern Bradford Door |
|
|
SemiHandmade
Agave Supermatte Glass Ready Shaker Door (thermofoil)
| $178.00 | 6-7 Weeks |
Nieu
Trendy Teal Shaker (painted mdf)
| $140.58 | 5-6 Weeks |
CabinetNow
Shaker Open for Glass (hardwood)
| $65.05 | 5-7 Business Days | Shaker Open for Glass |
|
|
SemiHandmade
Light Grey Supermatte Shaker Door (thermofoil)
| $171.00 | 6-7 Weeks |
Nieu
Whimsical White Shaker (painted mdf)
| $140.58 | 5-6 Weeks |
CabinetNow
Light Grey SmartMatte Modern Shaker (thermofoil
| $145.20 | 10-12 Business Days | Modern Shaker Door |
|
|
SemiHandmade
Light Grey Supermatte Slab Door (thermofoil)
| $156.00 | 6-7 Weeks |
Nieu
Whimsical White Scandia (painted mdf)
| $92.75 | 5-6 Weeks |
CabinetNow
Light Grey SmartMatte Modern Turino (thermofoil)
| $141.00 | 10-12 Business Days | Modern Turino Door |
|
|
SemiHandmade
Oakley Supermatte Slab Door (thermofoil)
| $156.00 | 6-7 Weeks |
Nieu
Rhapsody Wood Grain Slab Vertical Grain (TFL)
| $64.05 | 3-4 Weeks |
CabinetNow
Swiss Elm Matte Modern Turino (thermofoil)
| $99.60 | 10-12 Business Days | Modern Turino Door |
|
|
SemiHandmade
Tahoe Impression Door (textured melamine)
| $171.00 | 8 Weeks |
Nieu
Wood Grain Slab - Vertical Grain Door (TFL)
| $83.15 | 3-4 Weeks |
CabinetNow
Natural Rotary Birch Aries (Wood veneer)
| $77.00 | 5-7 Business Days | Aries Door |
|
|
SemiHandmade
Sonoma Impression Door (textured melamine)
| $171.00 | 8 Weeks |
Nieu
Rhapsody Wood Grain Slab Vertical Grain (TFL)
| $64.05 | 3-4 Weeks |
CabinetNow
Palomina Modern Turino(thermofoil)
| $99.60 | 10-12 Business Days | Modern Turino Door |
|
|
SemiHandmade
Beach Impression Door (textured melamine)
| $171.00 | 8 Weeks |
Nieu
Winter Fun Wood Grain Slab (TFL)
| $64.05 | 3-4 Weeks |
CabinetNow
Winter Fun Modern Turino (thermofoil)
| $99.60 | 10-12 Business Days | Modern Turino Door |
|
|
SemiHandmade
Walnut Slab Door (wood veneer)
| $311.00 | 8-10 Weeks |
Nieu
Wood Grain Slab Natural Walnut (TFL)
| $83.15 | 3-4 Weeks |
CabinetNow
Amati Walnut Modern Turino (thermofoil)
| $173.00 | 10-12 Business Days | Modern Turino Door |
|
Disclaimer: The prices and product information provided in this comparison were collected from the competitors' websites on 9/13/2024. We have made our best attempt to ensure accuracy, but prices and availability may vary over time. Please verify directly with the respective companies for the most up-to-date information.
CabinetNow Offers Affordable and High-Quality IKEA Replacement Cabinet Doors
CabinetNow offers a variety of finishes and materials at significantly lower prices compared to competitors like SemiHandMade. For example, while SemiHandMade’s DIY Shaker Door costs $95, you can get a similar style with CabinetNow’s Unfinished Shaker Cabinet Door ¾” for $65.05.
Similarly, our Modern Shaker Thermofoil Door in Ontario White is priced at just $108.90, offering a sleek, high-end look for far less than the competition. These options provide an affordable yet stylish upgrade for your kitchen, helping you achieve the aesthetic you want without overspending.
Customization Without the Price Tag
At CabinetNow, we understand that every kitchen is unique, and we pride ourselves on offering way more options than many competitors. Whether you're looking for a classic, modern, or custom style, you'll find a wide range of styles and finishes to match your vision. We offer more choices in finishes, materials, and customization than brands like SemiHandMade and Nieu, ensuring you get exactly what you need to create your dream kitchen.
Whether you prefer the natural warmth of wood grain finishes, the soft elegance of supermatte, or the sleek, high-end shine of gloss, CabinetNow has the perfect solution to fit both your design preferences and your budget. From unfinished cabinet doors that allow for DIY customization to pre-finished options in a variety of colors and textures, we provide more flexibility and variety than any other competitor in the market.
Not only do we offer an extensive selection, but our pricing also ensures that upgrading to IKEA replacement cabinet doors doesn't have to break the bank. With CabinetNow, you can achieve a fully customized look for far less, whether you're remodeling your kitchen, bathroom, or any other space in your home. No matter your style or budget, we have the options to meet your needs—more choices, better quality, and exceptional value.
Cost Savings Beyond the Cabinets
When comparing SemiHandMade to CabinetNow, it's important to consider the additional costs beyond just the price of cabinet doors. According to SemiHandmade’s website, creating a custom cart will cost you $99 (which is credited toward your order). However, with CabinetNow, creating your cart is completely free—no charge, no strings attached.
If you’re still finalizing your design or haven’t made up your mind, CabinetNow allows you to explore options and make changes to your order without worrying about fees. That means if you decide to switch styles or cancel, you’ve saved an additional $99 just by choosing CabinetNow—money you could spend elsewhere in your renovation.
Lead Time Comparison: How Much Time Can You Save?
One of the biggest factors when choosing a custom cabinet door supplier is the time it takes to deliver your order. Based on the data we’ve compared, CabinetNow clearly outpaces its competitors, offering 5-7 day lead times, compared to 5-7 weeks with other brands like SemiHandMade and Nieu.
Here's what this time difference means for your project:
- CabinetNow: With a 5-7 day lead time, you could have your custom cabinet doors delivered and ready for installation in just a week, allowing you to complete your kitchen renovation much faster. This is ideal for homeowners or contractors who need a quick turnaround.
- Competitors: On the other hand, SemiHandMade and Nieu typically require 5-7 weeks to deliver custom orders. This long waiting period could lead to significant delays, especially if you’re on a tight schedule or need your kitchen functional as soon as possible.
By choosing CabinetNow, you save weeks of waiting time, allowing you to move forward with your project faster and avoid the stress of lengthy delays. Not only will your kitchen be ready sooner, but you’ll also be able to enjoy the benefits of customization and affordability without the prolonged timeline.
Conclusion: CabinetNow vs. Competitors – The Clear Choice for IKEA Replacement Cabinet Doors
If you’re looking for high-quality custom cabinet doors at a price that won’t stretch your budget, CabinetNow is the clear choice. Whether you're updating your kitchen, bathroom, or any other part of your home, our selection offers the perfect balance of affordability and premium craftsmanship. Our competitive prices on popular styles like Shaker and Slab doors, combined with a wide range of finishes, allow you to achieve a high-end, customized look without breaking the bank.
At CabinetNow, we take pride in offering versatile designs that suit both modern and traditional aesthetics, ensuring you’ll find something that fits your unique style. From classic wood grains to sleek, contemporary finishes, our diverse range of materials and colors allows you to create the cabinets of your dreams, whether you're looking to match existing decor or completely transform a space.
Our expert team is here to guide you through the process, offering personalized advice and support, from selecting the right door style to finalizing your finishes. Plus, with our easy-to-use website, finding the perfect match for your home renovation project has never been simpler.
Don’t settle for overpriced options—discover the quality and value of CabinetNow. Please contact us for any questions. Browse our full range of finishes and styles today, and start your journey toward a beautifully refreshed home that reflects your vision!
